Official: CNC the signature above you

[_Dave_]

This will help everyone to improve their gfxing skill, commenting and giving constructive criticism on the tag.

RULES- no talking bad about their work simply notice what they are missing, or need improving and what's too much. oh and remember we don't want NUMBERS.

-Halla

[Rasta_Boy]

Ewwww lmao jk

I like the pen tool alot , and the blue tree (lol blue tree)xd
Text ish awesome, depth is A too ,
OVerall pretty FIne

[giantKon]

I like the colors. The lines on top of text look really-really good, but it would look even better if they would blend even more with the text (right now you can see the starting points of the lines). Backround - just awesome. It really fits with the font and the color.

[Rasta_Boy]

I like it
Nice text
NIce blending
Nice depth

Kepp workin good dude.

[Yoruichi10]

i like the userbar its a good blend and its symmetrical

[Tousen_Kaname]

I like it a lot very creative:) I wish I can gfx like, but I think I'm never going to be at the level where your atT-T.

[Mataa]

red text? O.o lol red is a bad combination with a blue bg xD and its a bit blury as well xD

[Alkemi]

Text a bit small for me but its still pwnsome ^^

[Freedom_yuuki]

i like but bit too bright just a little and txt kinda takes away the attention of gin

[Enko]

bottom one is better than the top the sasuke one is too messy IMO

[giantKon]

Speechless.. There's nothing bad or anything too much. Everything is.. balanced.

[Yoruichi10]

you need to work on the text and back ground needs work.

[Andreea]

~ i dont like the text
~pretty colors ^^

[giantKon]

really really messy, in my opinion.
text looks really good, and fits in.

[_Dave_]

nice style but too small ,text placed wrong place color balance other then dat nice sig

-Halla

[SethUchiha109]

It's ok, quality is bad though. I know it's vector but I suggest adding a little more on the sides.

[Yoruichi10]

9/10 it is 3D and the background is fantastic.

[Reborn]

i really have nothing bad to say about the sig maybe the color blending though:o:eek:

[Andreea]

- i dont' like the border

- bad text

- pretty colors ^^

[giantKon]

Same thing : D..
35 Characters
35 Characters

[Andreea]

umm its cool , but kinda dark XD

[Enma_Kon]

omg cool XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD not plain not dark its perfect

[hitsugaya_toushiro]

if itz kon it has 2 b a 10 on 10!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

.................................................. .........................................

[Andreea]

~bad text
~too blue XDD
~kinda plain o.o

[UnknownMercinary]

Ohhhh i like the explosive red really pretty, but its kinda hard to see some of the stuff because of the white-ing. I like the text but the red part is a little hard to read. (that is just in my opinoon of course im no expert) :)

[Reborn]

render doesnt go with background=o:eek:

[Andreea]

i dont like the border , bad text , pretty colors ^^

[SethUchiha109]

I like the lightning and the effects good text and good background, doesn't seem to need a border though.

[tray1223]

nice colors and good lightin jus turn down the contrast 8

[_Dave_]

i should whip u for makin dis , bad color,clear the noise, not feelin de dark spot and using dat many(same person) render in dat space bad choice.
come tray i've u make better sig

[Addiction]

its really awesome o:
not much to say about it, cept maybe some c4ds could have livened it up?

[caz]

8/10. xD
-------------------------

[_Dave_]

its really awesome o:
not much to say about it, cept maybe some c4ds could have livened it up?
nah c4d will too much on dat it i like it dis way lol thbx tho

@cez we ain't lookin for numbers dats de reason i put on CNC der is another topic fo that

[UnknownMercinary]

Your signature creeps me out ... i dont know why though but it does *good job on it but its creepy....... :(

[TRuSaint]

Sig #1 Is an overall nice sig... nice flow ;) 8.5/10
Sig #2 I don't like the background or the text, it doesn't look good with the render 4/10

[Freedom_yuuki]

Sig1:
I love it but a bit too bright in one of the spots kinda bleacds in

[Reborn]

i love both sigs there is nothing wrong with dem:o

[_Dave_]

nice style nice flow nice color but clear the noise sharp a bit work on text mate

[Freedom_yuuki]

ahh it's cool the txt placement is good and the i luv the smoke and c4d

[Andreea]

#1 its perfect ! =O
#2 it's kinda plain , umm and i dont like really much white&black sigs XDD

[purechakra1]

I like it Nice Texture and choice of colors

[Andreea]

umm kinda plain , bad border and text XD

[Enma_Kon]

its perfect =P
__________________________

[rangiku]

ok i like the lights in youre sig..the writing is ok and i like naruto thats very cute

[Andreea]

ummm not sig , just a pic XDDD

[Enma_Kon]

XDD again ok i like the effectsXDDDDDDDDDD

[Keeny]

Its colorful =O xP
The text could be improved though =x and it need depth i guess o-o

[Andreea]

i like it , but bad text XDD

[BoOoO]

is nice but bad text o.o

[Andreea]

ummmmm not sig >_>

[Keeny]

Its so nice i can't even describe it O=

[Andreea]

i like it , but bad text XDD

[Keeny]

Its so wonderful i can't even describe it X=

[giantKon]

Yeah, bad text and the bottom should be blurred less or less optic ( I really can't get, what it is ). But the backround is just.. amazing.

[Andreea]

not sig o.o

[Addiction]

theres nothing to CnC o,o
its like a perfect 10 xD

[Andreea]

umm i like it , its cool x]

[CaptainAizen]

the sig above me iz pretty good. i give it a 8.5/10. i like the colors.

[jonatangh]

like the top one better .

[CaptainTousen]

Who doesnt like chucky haha
.........................................

[Andreea]

~bad text
~ messy
~border sucks XD

[skyhawk19]

if just voted ur ava l.....................ike ur sig to tho

[Andreea]

umm its too dark and bad text o.o

[CaptainTousen]

Like it but the text could show a lil more

[Andreea]

~bad text
~ messy
~border sucks XD

[Enma_Kon]

i like it xDD
a little to lighty xD but very nice

[Rockster100]

Awesome!!!
____________________________

[Andreea]

~text sucks
~i dont like the colors
~plain

[L2v5]

-Background owns
-Text is too little (I barely can see it)

Not much things to say about your awesome sig :)

[Andreea]

~bad border
~kinda messy
~i dont like really much the text x]

[giantKon]

Andreea can't get the point..
In my opinion, your being rude. Only saying what's wrong, not saying how to make it better.
Messy as hell, looks like an newspaper.
Border's horrible.

[Andreea]

its cool i love the colors ! x]

[ZangetsuX]

well i like urs andreea i can't really tell wat it is but it's still pretty kool

[Andreea]

not sig , just a pic .

[ZangetsuX]

yea i no mine isn't very good i don't really care about it as long as there's something there i'm fine

[Andreea]

not sig , just a pic .

[Itachi_Uchiha]

nice background
awesome render XD
text a bit 2 small
border looks nice

[Andreea]

-kinda plain
-bad text
-bad border o.o

[Addiction]

its really good idk what to say o,o

[Andreea]

its cool but i dont like really much the text x]

[Sandmanxx23]

Too messy, looks dirty imo.
No blending, looks like a wet newspaper.
xD

[omiray]

9/10 i love pokemon and it has a good backround

[ZangetsuX]

7/10 i like the background!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[giantKon]

Let me know, when there's a signature that I could comment ; )).

[triplew]

8/10 interesting avatar looks kinda creepy though but good detail ^_^

[ulquiorra21]

i like the top sig better the bottom one is just useless u cant see ichigo's face and its plain bad text but keep the top one i like it

[Sandmanxx23]

The text is horrible, you brushed over the render, something you should never do.
Its way too messy, the c4d useage sucks.

[misterSado]

it doesn't flow all that well its randomish , and whatP random light, but its nice and hmm colorful

[vash812]

^MisterSado
You can't fail if you never try

Since my sig wont show http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m81/Vash812/BeserksigV1copy.png

[Amatsuka]

Its ok. Colors are bland and boring.
I like vibrant colors :D
Good sense of flow.
Text is a bit boring and too static for me. :/

[Sandmanxx23]

....Same as before.
Nice depth, not feeling the colors, and the focal is way too big.

[orochimaru]

7/10 its ok
_________

[Amatsuka]

Why bother posting if you've already rated mine. Thats just...-gag-

Anyhow, I like the simplicity here. Text is a little small. Maybe my eyes are just bad. I do think SOMETHING should be in the background besides pure white. Depth is well represented otherwise.
Border is a little gaudy too.
8/10

[misterSado]

hmm its kinda plainbut I like it , it has peaceful vibe , and maybe make the shine in eyes dif. color

[Sandmanxx23]

You dont have one so o.o.
Get a signature is my CnC. =o

[carsonnik]

The lighting isn't great, way too bright. It might look better darkened. 7/10

[Sasuke61694]

I like it, but text needs some work, it's a bit bright, a little messy, but other than that it's cool

[ZangetsuX]

number 1 is 8/10 but the 2nd one is a little hippe 6/10 but that's not the problem it's sort of bland 2 me

[Madvillian]

7/10 Render little blurry plain in like blend kinda way but yea

[Sasuke61694]

I like the concept and I havn't seen too many sigs of him, it's also a fairly unique style and it blends well, for CnC I guess I would say to learn somemore effects and try to incorporate more into your sig

[UnknownMercinary]

Ive rated you before and i think i gave an 8/10 and 7/10 so yeah there it is!!!

I know what your thinking: "Those sigs are so amazing, i cant let him know of my jealousy so ill say they suck." But i know what your really thinkinging so HAH!!! :):):):):)

[ngl619]

the text and border needs work

[Afro]

I like it it describes a bit how creative you are well done :)

[giantKon]

Aaaaw, so good looking but bad quality. Text isn't the best too : //.
Other than this , 9/10

[UnknownMercinary]

OK Kon i decided to like bygons be bygons and im gonna drop all the crap between us.
9/10 for the skill level/quality but the actual picture doesnt *intregue* (screw spelling) me that much so 8/10 overall.

[Alkemi]

Border needs work ... Text needs work... font needs work. Text is WAYYY to small on the bottom left. Plain.

[clangers]

a sig that glows of greatness makes me feel bad about mine.
Meant to tell you how to improve but i aint a genious in graphics and if it improved anymore my head would explode multiple times (yes it would reform then explode again)
10/10

[giantKon]

@UnknownMercinary- It's nice of you to "drop all the crap" : ).

But clangers, your signature is just an screenshot with an text on it.

[UnknownMercinary]

Border needs work ... Text needs work... font needs work. Text is WAYYY to small on the bottom left. Plain.

@ the guy above me i would cnc or w/e but i already have plenty of times plus my comp isnt letting me see any pictures right now so i couldnt if i wanted to.

I know my text needs work it always does, i dont pay attention to borders, and the text in the bottom is supposed to be small its my little indent into my sigs saying that i made it. Its on all my recent ones.

[clangers]

@UnknownMercinary- It's nice of you to "drop all the crap" : ).

But clangers, your signature is just an screenshot with an text on it.

its actualy not a screenshot...... watch all the eps ill doubt youll find it. If you do i didnt take it from there.

[Murdoc]

2/10... im sorry but i really dont like it, and u have no lessons to teach for u have no quotes to write for you have no imagination to think and without thinking you are...
IGNORANT

[Alkemi]

0/10 You didn't make it... Just a pic... No text. No border.. No bg... XD

[Hithero]

9/10 I Think It's Pretty Awesome :D

[giantKon]

@Clangers- That won't make it suck any less : ) .

@Hithero- I like the render, where di you get it : PP? But looks kind a epmty, there's about 3 brushes used on it only : //.

[Murdoc]

0/10 You didn't make it... Just a pic... No text. No border.. No bg... XD

Do you not know? a signature does not have to be a picture that u make but something expresses your self, when that has been done, you have reached true respect for your self

[EliteHitsugaya]

@Murdoc:0/10 Nothing good about it._.
@GiantKon:9/10 Nice Sig^^
@hithero:10/10 Thats An Awesome Sig you have Hit^^
@Alkemi:9/10 Good Render^^

[giantKon]

@Murdoc- None likes smarties you know.. And as we know, there are unwritten rules for a signature. Yours is just an RENDER with a white, plain, boring and empty background.

But Hitsugaya, too bad you don't have a signature : ((.

[EliteHitsugaya]

@GiantKon-I don't have A sig I know I have A PlayerCard,and something that says EliteHitsugaya on it

[Murdoc]

then i will go make a signature and be back with an awsome one, or i could just use and old one.

[giantKon]

Too dark, messy and one-colored. That other dude in the left is really hard to notice when you do a one-sec-look-on. Text in the other hand is really good, position isn't the best but not bad either.

[Alkemi]

Great sig. I love the colours! The lines on the right i hate them =.= xD

[giantKon]

Darn it. I thought it will look better 'cos that place at right looked kind a empty to me : DD. I used some kind of an scan line brush.

You signature. Fantastic render, where'd you find it : OO?! And again, text text text! It looks bad ; ((.. But the background feels kind a empty, but other than this, I don't know what makes me like that signature alot.

[Ulquiora4]

huh maybe a 8/10 not bad colors looks nice...

[Edward_Elric]

Its too blury and the text isn't that great.The logo needs to be cut.

[Freedom_yuuki]

7/10 the background is kinda messy and flow is kinda distorted but it's okay

[ashashi]

8/10 nice BG, render and bla, bla, bla. Might look even prettier with border thou

[Suzaku]

7.5/10

A bit empty in the middle

[giantKon]

Everything's like, really-really perfect, but that grunge vector curve at the left looks really really bad, especially with that ugly glow. I'll give it a 8/10.

[SethUchiha109]

Uhm, I really cant see the stock or render or whatnot. But I really like the sig/tag. The background is kindad simple but eh, it's ok. 8/10

[Hyonimaru]

Yah. I get to criticize Seth.
=D
Lol.
I like everything. Background is kinda plain for me though.
8/10

[_Dave_]

Seth sig isn't plain, just the style of vector.

anyways your sig-
lack of, depth, flow, light source, text, blending. oh and render--> doesn't fit you at any way! lol

am pretty sure you can do better compared to your mix tape shit! that was good.

you both keep it up.

wow, first time i posted in my own Topic ever since i made it! xd

[Gokurules]

what could i possibly cnc about its awesome

[Hyonimaru]

@Dave..
Shushh..That's a old siggy.
=P
Lol..
Same as my current one also.

~Now doing the Goku..I think it needs a better blend.
Im not feeling the Yellow and Blue.

[giantKon]

That stock/render looks stretched and the text isn't good. But I LOVE IT. It looks so good. Like, those colors .. UGHH, It's too good!

[Freedom_yuuki]

very bright no focal giantKon just wasn't your day right? 6/10

[giantKon]

Well, I like it and I don't care what others say. It's not like I'm doing them for others to see -.-".. And I don't get those focal points :?
I don't know about the colored version but I'd say it would look better. There are 2 places ( shoulder areas ) that make the render/stock feel so called "out of space". But still, I like it and it's 8.5/10.

[Hitsugaya09]

awesome it looks ok 2 me nice work

[Hyonimaru]

I don't like the background.
Better blend would do good too.
Change that black text to be more readable.

[UnknownMercinary]

im pretty sure CnC means Critique and Credits? Or something like that so ima say...VERY NOICE i loves it, a fraction distorted but i still love it. Only main thing i dont like is the shine in the top left but other than that G R E A T !!! SUPERMAN FTW!

[giantKon]

There are so many things that I dislike, and nothing that I like so I won't better start with my thing, I'm gonna save you from this : ).

[Suzaku]

9/10

I like the whole sig put together.... and who is she? Your Gf?

[giantKon]

I just found that stock you used on your signature and I like the fact that you've add some effects by yourself do it too. Again, scanlines- don't use them to fill up empty spaces. Same thing goes to that halftone thing. It's like that signature is only half made- I don't feel the background, it's too empty. I like the text, really cool effects under it. And the white glowing brush on the right side- too random.
8/10 IF it had a good background : ).

Maybe she is, maybe she's not.

[Suzaku]

I didn't know what to put there..... I NEVER do in empty spaces!!!! T_T

[giantKon]

Fact stays, and the same comment.
*hint* I've a new signature, CnC it *hint*

[Suzaku]

I like it too 9.5/10... what would you recommend me to put in the empty space of my sig?

[TRuSaint]

I love the flow and the background on that sig ;) I would add more to the left side
9/10

[giantKon]

@Suzaku- if you can use C4D, then try it, if you can't.. then still, give it a try : DD. But you can use abstract and grunge styled brushes with different layer effects.

@TRuSaint- It kind a looks blurred and that's what bothers me the most. And it has that techno/future-styled background which really doesn't go with Ichigo. And that font, it's supposed to be used on size 12 and with "None" text effect (text effects- sharpen, crisp, strong, etc.).

7/10, sorry, but that's how it is.

[Amatsuka]

Cool stock!
The text is almost invisible. I'm a more upfront text kind of guy :P
It's a nice piece of work though.
9/10

[Hellcats666]

9/10
I like the coloring and shades. I would say the background is totally barren but considering the show is based in a desert it makes sense to have it look like that i guess. I like how the text is prominent without being a distraction. The eyes on vash are also nice looking. I don't see to many problems with it that don't fit with the actual style.

[Bo0ts]

It's a giant kon work... nothing i can comment on... Its beautiful...
I love the render aswell~

10/10

[UnknownMercinary]

A Little bit too dark boots, but overall good. I especially like the text although you made it the main focal point.
8.2/10

[ColdLightnin]

A lot of paintbrushes but it look good to messy and crappy render..
7/10

[rumjello]

awsome 8/10 the clash of blue uhh im not feeling it

[BlackVizard]

like the color and the brightness i think it totally goes with the smile thats on her face also like the effect used on the right side of the sig xD

this is taken from the first post in this thread by the thread starter Dave

This will help everyone to improve their gfxing skill, commenting and giving constructive criticism on the tag.

RULES- no talking bad about their work simply notice what they are missing, or need improving and what's too much. oh and remember we don't want NUMBERS.

-Halla

[Hellcats666]

6/10

The text needs work and the background doesn't blend and/or flow with the render very well.

[SoulVenom]

seen it b4 2/10...............

[Hyonimaru]

Change the background, Change the text. More depth, and more blending as well.

[lastave]

Shouldnt you kknow whut Photo EditingSystem they use first befoe you rate it

[acidrain11]

uuuh no plus this isnt the rating thread its the cnc thread photo editing system doesnt matter at all.

[sasorifan1]

idk whos in that that sig but work on the blending but i still like it 6/10

[Aexon]

the first one is good. the second one is nice but i don't like the things on the right of hinata. it kinda throws it off for me.

[Pauratagashi]

I like the Daisuke sig, the different colored lights do add to the sig's appeal. However, I feel that the depth still needs a little work. You can barely tell that there's a shadow on his pants. Also the sky on Daisuke's left side looks quite dull and unsaturated. Perhaps, adding a bit of dark blue to it and putting it on soft light or overlay? Or maybe multiply at a very small opacity? Anyways, it's still pretty good and I do like the color choice.

[Bo0ts]

Good sig overall, Text is bad, more depth would be good, Render might be a bit too light.

[Aexon]

need to learn how to blend c4ds. smudging them won't work all the time. should sharpen the face a bit more and the purple is random

[Hyonimaru]

Needs more effects, better blending, and a better focal to me.
Bo0ts render doesnt need to sharpen, i think it's fine if he's working with dark colors.

[Pauratagashi]

The sig is stretched too wide and squashed down. Also the fact that it's just a manga scan and nothing was added or messed with kinda bugs me.

[Veevin]

Certainly a messy piece. The lighting needs a lot of work because the random light sources doesn't appeal to the focal itself. Needs work on composition and effects basically. The text doesn't really give out that much which is alright but it's sort of not what it needs. Take out the bar at the left because it's interrupting the concept of the piece. The borders around the whole piece is pretty thick, I suggest on making the border at least 1 pixeled.

[Karma]

It's messy, but you worked it out with a great focal point. There isn't a certain light source here. That C4D on the left (that retro colored) kind a disturbs me.. Way too out-standing I guess.